URL: http://www.newsflashenglish.com/160408press2.html
Download FREE English lesson:
Slovak press run blank front pages
Ideas and Articles by David Robinson
16th April, 2008
Category: Current Affairs / Media / Press Act
Level: Intermediate / Upper intermediate
This lesson is the copyright of www.newsflashenglish.com
|
Slovak press run blank front pages Slovakia’s leading daily newspapers have come out with blank front pages in protest at a two-day old media law they say undermines press freedom. The papers on Friday ran empty front pages apart from a call for the abolition of the law, which was approved despite condemnation from human rights groups and the media. “The parliament approved a media law that is a gross interference into the freedom of the press and editorial independence,” the newspapers said in the front page protest. “We are appealing to the president, the constitutional court and international organisations to allow newspapers to continue serving their readers,” they said. Both tabloid and broadsheet dailies object chiefly to a clause that forces newspapers to run responses from people they have reported on, even if the published information is true. The media fear they will be overwhelmed by politicians’ requests to print their reactions. The law, replacing the existing one that dates back 42 years, also sparked a drawn-out fight over the approval of the European Union’s landmark treaty on institutional reform, the Treaty of Lisbon, as the opposition had threatened to block the ratification of it unless Prime Minister Robert Fico toned down the bill. Fico refused to accept the opposition’s main demands, but eventually won support for the EU Treaty after the ethnic Hungarian SMK party broke ranks with other opposition factions and helped the government push through the document on Thursday. The media law awaits signature by President Ivan Gasparovic. He has not made any comment on the law but he has good relations with the Fico administration. The country’s union of publishers and some opposition parties said they would consider challenging the law either in Slovak or European courts. The Press Act adjusts the rights and duties of the publishers of periodicals, as well as those of news agencies regarding the collecting and dissemination of information. Apart from the current right for correction of information in an equally prominent space as the misinformation was published, the new act introduces a right to reply. As well, protection of the source is defined as an obligation. According to the new act, publishers won’t be responsible for the content of the information that has been provided by a public body, or by a budgetary, or quasi-state organisation, or a legal entity on the assumption that the information is correct. The new law states the obligation for publishers to publish an announcement on the structure of ownership relations of the publishers every year in the first issue of the periodical. One of the most controversial parts of the new legislation is that the right to reply applies equally whether the information published is true or not. Leftist leader Fico, who has clashed with the media since taking power in 2006 says, “Most of them are critical of my welfare policies.” He rejected allegations that the law would offer limitless press access for politicians. Fico has said the bill is only aimed at giving even chances to ordinary people whose reputation may suffer as a result of a published story. The Slovak premier’s tactics are unheard-of in Europe. The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe, a rights and democratic watchdog, reiterated its earlier criticism of the law. Miklos Haraszti, the OSCE’S media freedom representative: “I deeply regret the situation that the new Press Act will create for the Slovak media…Yesterday’s vote offers politicians undue influence over the opinion content of all newspapers.” The Association of European Journalists (AEJ) on Thursday criticised the act perceiving its suppression of press freedom. It said the legislation is motivated by the intension to gain control of the media and to dictate to them how to secure balanced reporting based on the principles of freedom of speech. According to the AEJ: “It is like the ruling power wants to assume the role of the tamer of the media and appropriate the right to fashion and edit them. It zeroed in on the enforcement of the right of reply, which in its legislative formulations stands on feet of clay and is a mockery of other European states. The new law circumvents the rights of thousands of media producers.” Once signed by the president the new Press Act should become effective on 1st June 2008.* *Source: Stuff (New Zealand), Pravda, Slovakia Today, T.A.S.R. (Slovakia) |
1. NEW PRESS ACT IN SLOVAKIA: What do you know about the new Press Act in Slovakia? Is a good or bad piece of legislation? Are you for it or against it? Go round the room swapping stories. Change partners often.
2. DICTATION: The teacher will read some of the article slowly and clearly. Students will write down what they hear. The teacher will repeat the passage slowly again. Self correct your work from page 2 - filling in spaces and correcting mistakes. Be honest with yourself on the number of errors. Advise the teacher of your total number of errors. Less than 5 is very good. 10 are acceptable. Any more is room for improvement! More than 20 - we need to do some work!
3. READING: Get students to read the passage aloud. Swap readers every paragraph.
4. VOCABULARY: Students look through the article. Underline/highlight any vocabulary you do not know. Look in dictionaries. Discuss and help each other out. The teacher will go through & explain any words or phrases you do not understand.
5. EXPLAIN: Explain the following: blank front pages / undermines press freedom / abolition of the law / condemnation / human right groups / gross interference / freedom of the press / editorial interference / constitutional court / serving their readers / tabloid and broadsheet dailies / chiefly / sparked a drawn-out fight / institutional reform / ratification / toned down / ethnic / broke ranks / adjusts / periodicals / dissemination of information / equally prominent space / protection of the source / obligation / quasi-state organisation / reputation / tactics / reiterated / suppression / zeroed in / enforcement / freedom of speech / tamer of the media / circumvents / Leftist / welfare policies / allegations / unheard-of / regret
6. THE NEW PRESS ACT IN SLOVAKIA: Think of three advantages and disadvantages of the new Press Act in Slovakia. Compare and discuss with your partner(s).
Advantages
Disadvantages
1
1
2
2
3
3
The teacher will choose some pairs to discuss their findings in front of the class.
7. PRESS ACT: With your partner on the board write as many words to do with ‘Press Act’ as you can. One-two minutes. Compare with other teams. Discuss together – linking your words.
8. SENTENCES: Choose six/nine of the words from no 7. Write two/three sentences using two/three words in each. Underline your chosen words. The teacher will if necessary correct your work. Students might be asked to read their sentences aloud.
9. QUICK DEBATE ON THE NEW PRESS ACT: Students A are members of the government. They believe the new Press Act in Slovakia is a good thing as the current one needed updating. Explain why. Students B are opposition members. You definitely don’t agree with it. Explain why.
10. ARTICLE QUIZ: With your partner or in small groups: (1 point for each correct answer. Lose ½ point if you look at the article for help!)
Student A
1) What
happened on Friday?
2) What did Fico tone down?
3) What
is the Treaty of Lisbon about?
4) What does the media law
await?
5) What did the Slovak union of publishers
say?
6) Sum up what was put on the front pages of the daily
newspapers.
7) What do the media fear?
8) Name the ethnic
Hungarian party
9) Who has not made any comment on the new
law?
10) What do the tabloid and broadsheets dailies object
chiefly to?
Student
B
1) How
old is the current Press Act?
2) What did Fico refuse to
accept?
3) Who will consider challenging the law in
court?
4) Which courts might the challenge go to?
5) Who
broke ranks?
6) What happened on Thursday?
7) When will
the new Press Act become effective?
8) Who criticised the act on
Thursday?
9) Sum up the OSCE’s feelings.
10) Name two
points in the new Press Act.
11. I ATTENDED THE SLOVAK PARLIAMENTARY SESSION OF THE PRESS ACT VOTE & SAW…: Think of 10 things you might have seen had you been at the parliamentary session of the Press Act vote. Write them below. Compare and discuss with your partner.
1
6
2
7
3
8
4
9
5
10
The teacher will choose some pairs to discuss their findings in front of the class.
12. THE TREATY OF LISBON: What do you know about the Treaty of Lisbon? Discuss with your partner.
13. QUICK DEBATE ON THE TREATY OF LISBON: Students A are for ratifying the Treaty of Lisbon. Explain why. Students B are against it. Explain why.
14. UN-SCRAMBLE: Put the following into the right order:
Easy
1) pages
Friday papers blank ran on front the
2) are the appealing
president to we
3) law a approved media parliament
4) papers law the called the abolition the of for
5) old
Act the is current years Press 42
Harder
6) demands
refused the Fico accept opposition to
7) had of opposition the
Lisbon of threatened the ratification the Treaty
8) The media law
awaits the signature by a president
9) He any has not made law
comment the on
10) a gross the is interference into the law
freedom the of press
(Answers are on page 15 – sentences adapted from article)
15. SENTENCE STARTERS: With your partner(s), finish these sentence starters. Change partner(s) and talk about the sentences you made.
Daily newspapers _______________________________________________
The papers ___________________________________________________
The law _______________________________________________________
The Press Act __________________________________________________
Fico said, ______________________________________________________
The opposition __________________________________________________
1. TRUE / FALSE: After reading the article guess whether these sentences are true (T) or false (F):
|
a. |
The current Slovak Press Act is 42 years old |
T / F |
|
b. |
Slovakia’s leading newspapers ran blank front pages recently |
T / F |
|
c. |
The Treaty of Lisbon is about EU enlargement |
T / F |
|
d. |
The Slovak opposition are in favour of the new Press Act |
T / F |
|
e. |
The Association of European Journalists is in favour of the new act |
T / F |
|
f. |
Press freedom is guaranteed in the new Press Act |
T / F |
|
g. |
Other European countries have similar press acts |
T / F |
|
h. |
Newspaper editors are delighted by the new Press Act |
T / F |
2. SYNONYM MATCH: Match the following synonyms from the article:
|
a. |
Blank |
Blackmail |
|
b. |
Abolition |
Started |
|
c. |
Undermine |
Huge |
|
d. |
Gross |
Stop |
|
e. |
Sparked |
Tribal |
|
f. |
Fight |
Thwart |
|
g. |
Threatened |
Reduce |
|
h. |
Block |
Removal |
|
i. |
Tone down |
Debate |
|
j. |
Ethnic |
Empty |
3. PHRASE MATCH: Match the following phrases from the article:
|
a. |
Slovakia’s leading daily newspapers |
to continue serving their readers |
|
b. |
The papers on Friday |
signature by President Ivan Gasparovic |
|
c. |
The media fear |
not made any comment on the law |
|
d. |
The law, |
block the ratification of it… |
|
e. |
Fico refused to |
they would consider challenging the law… |
|
f. |
The media law awaits |
accept the opposition’s main demands |
|
g. |
He has |
they will be overwhelmed by politicians’ … |
|
h. |
…some opposition parties said |
have come out with blank front pages |
|
i. |
…to allow newspapers |
replacing the existing one |
|
j. |
…the opposition had threatened to |
ran empty front pages |
Put the words into the gaps in the text.
|
Slovak press run blank front pages Slovakia’s leading daily __________ have come out with blank front pages in protest at a two-day old media law they say undermines _____ _______. The papers on Friday ran empty front pages apart from a call for the abolition of the law, which was approved despite condemnation from human rights groups and the media. “The parliament approved a _____ law that is a gross interference into the freedom of the press and editorial independence,” the newspapers said in the front page _______. “We are appealing to the president, the constitutional court and international organisations to allow newspapers to continue serving their readers,” they said. Both _______ and __________ _______ object chiefly to a clause that forces newspapers to run responses from people they have reported on, even if the published information is true. The media fear they will be overwhelmed by politicians’ requests to print their reactions.
|
|
dailies broadsheet tabloid press protest freedom media newspapers |
|
The law, replacing the existing one that dates back 42 years, also sparked a drawn-out _____ over the ________ of the European Union’s landmark treaty on institutional reform, the ______ of Lisbon, as the opposition had threatened to block the ratification of it unless Prime Minister Robert Fico toned down the ____. Fico refused to accept the opposition’s main demands, but eventually won support for the EU Treaty after the ______ Hungarian SMK party broke ranks with other __________ factions and helped the government push through the document on Thursday. The media ___ awaits signature by President Ivan Gasparovic. He has not made any comment on the law but he has good relations with the Fico administration. The country’s union of __________ and some opposition parties said they would consider challenging the law either in Slovak or European courts.
|
|
bill ethnic Treaty approval publishers opposition fight law |
Slovak press run blank front pages
Slovakia’s leading daily newspapers have come out with _________________ in protest at a two-day old media law they say undermines press freedom. The papers on Friday ran empty front pages apart __________________ abolition of the law, which was approved despite condemnation from human rights groups and the media. “The parliament approved a ___________________ gross interference into the freedom of the press and editorial independence,” the newspapers said in the front page protest. “We are appealing to the president, the ____________________ and international organisations to allow newspapers to continue serving their readers,” they said. Both ______________________ dailies object chiefly to a clause that forces newspapers to run responses from people they have reported on, even if the published information is true. The media __________________ overwhelmed by politicians’ requests to print their reactions.
The law, replacing the existing one that dates back 42 years, also sparked a drawn-out fight over ___________________ European Union’s landmark treaty on institutional reform, the ________________, as the opposition had threatened to block the ratification of it unless Prime Minister Robert Fico toned down the bill. Fico refused to accept the opposition’s main demands, but eventually won support _________________ after the ethnic Hungarian SMK party broke ranks with other opposition factions and helped the government push through the document on Thursday. The media law awaits signature by President Ivan Gasparovic. ___________________ comment on the law _______________ relations with the Fico administration. The country’s union of publishers and some opposition parties said they would consider challenging _________________ Slovak or European courts.
STUDENT A’s QUESTIONS (Do not show these to student B)
Did the headline make you want to read the article?
What do really think about the new Press Act?
Do you think the newspapers were right to run a blank front page?
What do you think the newspaper editors will do next?
Do you think the new Press Act in Slovakia will mean the end of the freedom of the press there?
Do you think the President of Slovakia will sign the new Press Act?
Why do think the President of Slovakia has not made any comment on this act?
Why has the new Press Act been so controversial?
Are you for or against the new act?
Why are press so opposed to this new act? Surely the right to reply by any individual is only fair?
?---------------------------------------------------------------------
STUDENT B’s QUESTIONS (Do not show these to student A)
Are you for or against freedom of speech?
Do you think other EU government’s will follow Slovakia’s footsteps and introduce similar laws?
What do you think the EU will think about the new law?
Is it right for a government to gain control of its media?
Do you think Slovakia is about to follow Russia’s footsteps in its suppression of its press?
Do you support the government in its new Press Act?
What do your friends think of the new Press Act?
Why do you think the government has introduced this Press Act?
Do you think the press has had too much power in Slovakia in recent years?
Did you like this discussion?
AFTER DISCUSSION: Join another partner / group and tell them what you talked about.
What was the most interesting thing you heard?
Was there a question you did not like?
Was there something you totally disagreed with?
What did you like talking about?
Which was the most difficult question?
Slovakia’s leading (1)__ newspapers have come out with (2)__ front pages in protest at a two-day old media law they say undermines press freedom. The papers on Friday ran empty front pages apart from a call for the abolition of the law, which was approved (3)__ condemnation from human rights groups and the media. “The parliament approved a media law that is a gross interference into the (4)__ of the press and editorial independence,” the newspapers said in the (5)__ page protest. “We are appealing to the president, the constitutional court and international organisations to allow newspapers to continue serving their readers,” they said. Both tabloid and broadsheet dailies object chiefly to a (6)__ that forces newspapers to run responses from people they have reported on, even if the published information is true. The media fear they will be overwhelmed by politicians’ requests to print their reactions.
The law, replacing the existing one that dates back 42 years, also sparked a drawn-out fight over the approval of the European Union’s (7)__ treaty on institutional reform, the Treaty of Lisbon, as the opposition had threatened to block the ratification of it unless Prime Minister Robert Fico toned down the bill. Fico refused to accept the opposition’s main demands, but eventually won support for the EU Treaty after the ethnic Hungarian SMK party broke ranks with other opposition factions and helped the government push through the document on Thursday. The media law (8)__ signature by President Ivan Gasparovic. He has not made any comment on the law but he has good relations with the Fico administration. The (9)__ union of publishers and some opposition parties said they (10)__ consider (11)__ the law either in Slovak or European (12)__.
|
1. |
(a) |
daily |
(b) |
weekly |
(c) |
monthly |
(d) |
yearly |
|
2. |
(a) |
empty |
(b) |
blank |
(c) |
red |
(d) |
black |
|
3. |
(a) |
despite |
(b) |
in spite |
(c) |
spite |
(d) |
fight |
|
4. |
(a) |
liberty |
(b) |
freedom |
(c) |
free |
(d) |
kingdom |
|
5. |
(a) |
front |
(b) |
back |
(c) |
inside |
(d) |
empty |
|
6. |
(a) |
claws |
(b) |
pause |
(c) |
clause |
(d) |
jaws |
|
7. |
(a) |
landfill |
(b) |
landmark |
(c) |
landmine |
(d) |
landscape |
|
8. |
(a) |
waits |
(b) |
awaits |
(c) |
awaiting |
(d) |
awaited |
|
9. |
(a) |
county |
(b) |
country |
(c) |
country’s |
(d) |
countries |
|
10. |
(a) |
should |
(b) |
would |
(c) |
could |
(d) |
wood |
|
11. |
(a) |
challenge |
(b) |
challenges |
(c) |
challenging |
(d) |
challenged |
|
12. |
(a) |
cities |
(b) |
courts |
(c) |
palaces |
(d) |
theatres |
Put the words into the gaps in the text.
|
Slovak press run blank front pages Slovakia’s leading daily newspapers have come out (1)____ blank front pages in protest at a two-day old media law they say undermines press freedom. The papers on Friday ran empty front pages apart (2)____ a call for the abolition of the law, (3)_____ was approved despite condemnation from human rights groups and the media. “The parliament approved a media law that is a gross interference (4)____ the freedom of the press and editorial independence,” the newspapers said in the front page protest. “We are appealing to the president, the constitutional court and international organisations to allow newspapers to continue serving their readers,” they said. Both tabloid and broadsheet dailies object chiefly to a clause (5)____ forces newspapers to run responses from people they have reported on, (6)____ if the published information is true. The media fear (7)____ will be overwhelmed by politicians’ requests to print (8)_____ reactions.
|
|
they from with into their even that which |
|
The law, replacing the existing one that dates back 42 years, (1)____ sparked a drawn-out fight over the approval of the European Union’s landmark treaty on institutional reform, the Treaty of Lisbon, as the opposition had threatened to block the ratification of it unless Prime Minister Robert Fico toned down the bill. Fico refused to accept the opposition’s main demands, but eventually won support for the EU Treaty (2)____ the ethnic Hungarian SMK party broke ranks (3)____ (4)____ opposition factions and helped the government push (5)_____ the document on Thursday. The media law awaits signature by President Ivan Gasparovic. He has not made any comment on the law but he has good relations with the Fico administration. The country’s union of publishers and (6)____ opposition parties said they (7)____ consider challenging the law (8)_____ in Slovak or European courts.
|
|
some through other with also either would after |
Put the words into the gaps in the text.
|
Slovak press run blank front pages Slovakia’s leading daily newspapers have come out with blank front pages in protest at a two-day old media law they say undermines press freedom. The papers (1)__ Friday ran empty front pages apart from a call (2)__ the abolition of (3)__ law, which was approved despite condemnation from human rights groups and the media. “The parliament approved (4)__ media law that is a gross interference into the freedom of the press (5)__ editorial independence,” the newspapers said in the front page protest. “(6)__ are appealing to the president, the constitutional court and international organisations to allow newspapers (7)__ continue serving their readers,” they said. Both tabloid and broadsheet dailies object chiefly to a clause that forces newspapers to run responses from people they have reported on, even if the published information is true. The media fear they will be overwhelmed (8)__ politicians’ requests to print their reactions.
|
|
we by on for a and to the |
|
The law, replacing the existing one that dates back 42 years, also sparked a drawn-out fight over the approval (1)__ the European Union’s landmark treaty on institutional reform, the Treaty of Lisbon, (2)__ the opposition had threatened to block (3)__ ratification of (4)__ unless Prime Minister Robert Fico toned down the bill. Fico refused to accept the opposition’s main demands, (5)__ eventually won support for the EU Treaty after the ethnic Hungarian SMK party broke ranks with other opposition factions and helped the government push through the document on Thursday. The media law awaits signature by President Ivan Gasparovic. He has not made any comment (6)__ the law but (7)__ has good relations with the Fico administration. The country’s union of publishers and some opposition parties said they would consider challenging the law either in Slovak (8)__ European courts.
|
|
but it as he of or on the |
1. NEWSPAPER ARTICLE: Write an article on “The new Press Act in Slovakia” (You may need to use the internet for this!) (Minimum 200 words)
2. NEWSPAPER ARTICLE: Write an article on “Why Slovak newspapers ran blank front pages” (You may need to use the internet for this!) (Minimum 200 words)
Read what you wrote to your classmates in the next lesson. Which article was best and why?
WRITING: IN CLASS:
1. FIVE MINUTE ARTICLE: Write an article on “The new Press Act in Slovakia” You have five minutes. Afterwards swap articles with your partner. Read through their article and correct any mistakes. The teacher will select some students to read out their work. Countdown: Every minute the teacher may say, “You have xx minutes.”
2. FIVE MINUTE ARTICLE: Write an article on “Why Slovak newspapers ran blank front pages” You have five minutes. Afterwards swap articles with your partner. Read through their article and correct any mistakes. The teacher will select some students to read out their work. Countdown: Every minute the teacher may say, “You have xx minutes.”
SPELLING TEST
The
teacher will ask the class individually to spell the following words
that are in the article:
ANSWERS:
2 12.
UN-SCRAMBLED: (adapted
from article)
Easy
1 newspapers
11 despite
2 abolition
12 overwhelmed
3 broadsheet
13 factions
4 eventually
14 information
5 through
15 reactions
6 opposition
16 politicians’
7 challenging
17 institutional
8 interference
18 approval
9 protest
19 landmark
10 editorial
20 ratification
1) The
papers on Friday ran blank front pages
2) We are appealing to the
president
3) Parliament approved a media law
4) The
papers called for the abolition of the law
5) The current Press
Act is 42 years old
Harder
6) Fico
refused to accept the opposition demands
7) The opposition had
threatened the ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon
8) The media law
awaits a signature by the president
9) He has not made any comment
on the law
10) The law is a gross interference into the freedom
of the press
TRUE / FALSE:
|
a. T |
b. F |
c. T |
d. F |
e. T |
f. T |
g. F |
h. F |
SYNONYM MATCH:
|
a. |
Blank |
Empty |
|
b. |
Abolition |
Removal |
|
c. |
Undermine |
Thwart |
|
d. |
Gross |
Huge |
|
e. |
Sparked |
Started |
|
f. |
Fight |
Debate |
|
g. |
Threatened |
Blackmail |
|
h. |
Block |
Stop |
|
i. |
Tone down |
Reduce |
|
j. |
Ethnic |
Tribal |
PHRASE MATCH:
|
a. |
Slovakia’s leading daily newspapers |
have come out with blank front pages |
|
b. |
The papers on Friday |
ran empty front pages |
|
c. |
The media fear |
they will be overwhelmed by politicians’ … |
|
d. |
The law, |
replacing the existing one |
|
e. |
Fico refused to |
accept the opposition’s main demands |
|
f. |
The media law awaits |
signature by President Ivan Gasparovic |
|
g. |
He has |
not made any comment on the law |
|
h. |
…some opposition parties said |
they would consider challenging the law… |
|
i. |
…to allow newspapers |
to continue serving their readers |
|
j. |
…the opposition had threatened to |
block the ratification of it… |
GAP FILL: Slovak press run blank front pages: Slovakia’s leading daily newspapers have come out with blank front pages in protest at a two-day old media law they say undermines press freedom. The papers on Friday ran empty front pages apart from a call for the abolition of the law, which was approved despite condemnation from human rights groups and the media. “The parliament approved a media law that is a gross interference into the freedom of the press and editorial independence,” the newspapers said in the front page protest. “We are appealing to the president, the constitutional court and international organisations to allow newspapers to continue serving their readers,” they said. Both tabloid and broadsheet dailies object chiefly to a clause that forces newspapers to run responses from people they have reported on, even if the published information is true. The media fear they will be overwhelmed by politicians’ requests to print their reactions. The law, replacing the existing one that dates back 42 years, also sparked a drawn-out fight over the approval of the European Union’s landmark treaty on institutional reform, the Treaty of Lisbon, as the opposition had threatened to block the ratification of it unless Prime Minister Robert Fico toned down the bill. Fico refused to accept the opposition’s main demands, but eventually won support for the EU Treaty after the ethnic Hungarian SMK party broke ranks with other opposition factions and helped the government push through the document on Thursday. The media law awaits signature by President Ivan Gasparovic. He has not made any comment on the law but he has good relations with the Fico administration. The country’s union of publishers and some opposition parties said they would consider challenging the law either in Slovak or European courts.
LANGUAGE WORK
|
1 - a |
2 - b |
3 - a |
4 - b |
5 - a |
6 - c |
7 – b |
8 - b |
9 - c |
10 - b |
11 - c |
12 – b |